You had either observed or heard from others about the high or low voltage supply problem at one’s house. The doubt, most of the time, goes to the poor quality of supply voltage or voltage surge. But there is another reason also and, i.e. ‘Neutral Disconnect’. In this post, we will examine how neutral disconnect and its location affects your power supply performance.
The power supply to your house is either single-phase, i.e. 2-wire with phase and neutral or 4-wire with 3 phase and neutral. Read more on single and three-phase supply. A power supply is distributed in parallel to the various house either single-phase or three-phase supply system depending on the sanctioned load. The transformer at the substation is delta-star connected wherein the input is 3-wire 3 phase, and the output of the transformer is 4-wire 3 phase. Depending on the load, the power company sanctions either single or three-phase supply to your house. When it is a single-phase, alternately the power is distributed from the R, Y and B phase so that the load on the system is balanced.
What is a neutral Terminal?
The neutral connection is taken out from the transformer by which one gets the supply between phase and neutral as 240V. This neutral wire is earthed at the transformer itself and run as insulated wire to the house. The earthing of the neutral terminal keeps the neutral tied at earth potential. It helps in maintaining the phase potential at 240 V minus a few volts towards voltage drop. Due to unbalance of load, some current always flows through the neutral wire back to the system. Remember that the neutral is only earthed at the transformer and not at the load, i.e. house. One should not earth the neutral at his house. In that case, part of the current may flow to the source though earth with some power loss.
What is Neutral Disconnection?
Neutral disconnection is similar to phase disconnection. If the phase supply is disconnected, you don’t get power in your house in that phase and no damage done. Now imagine neutral disconnects at the scenario given below and how the voltage behaves at the terminal of various phases.
At the transformer
The transformer is feeding load in all the three-phase, and distribution is such that load is balanced within plus/minus 5-15%. Due to the disconnection of neutral at the transformer, its potential will be floating depending on the load unbalance. Now if the load unbalance is significant say plus-minus 15%, the phase having a low load, the voltage will go high and the electronic equipment provided in that phase may burn and reduce the load further any may start a domino effect. In the meantime, phase having high load will experience low voltage but will not cause any damage to electronics/light/fan. But it may damage the motor-operated equipment, and it catches smoke or flames, will reduce the load in that phase or isolated due to protection of stabiliser action. In any case, the load is reduced, and voltage going high. The neutral may now shift to stability, and the sequence of damages to the equipment may stop.
It is how it explains the complaints about damaging of equipment in the society and every apartment/house experience this problem.
At your house
The load unbalance will be significant, and the voltage unbalance will also be high. There is a likelihood of substantial damage to the electronic equipment in lines with the phenomenon explained above.
At the house with single-phase connection
Since the neutral is disconnected, there will not be any power supply in the house. You will search for the MCB or RCCB, but no tripping and then what? The natural disconnect will result in phase voltage appearing at the neutral terminal. It can be detected by checking with the tester only. Make sure this testing is done with the help of an electrician.
Neutral disconnect but touches the ground
Ah! It is the safest mode of disconnect when neutral disconnect and touched the ground. Now the return current flows back to source through the earth. The potential of neutral does not shift much and no damage to any equipment.
How often it happens?
With overhead LT distribution network, this can be a common phenomenon during storms and particularly in villages with improper maintenance of neutral conductor. This is one of the reasons that the villagers will use earth as the return conductor instead neutral because there is no reliability of the overhead wires. In early days, overhead LT distribution was widespread in cities, but at that time electronic or motor-driven appliances were also not very common in the houses and not much of a complaint. With LT distribution by a cable network, there is very unlikelihood of such incidences except when there is maintenance lapse.
What is the solution?
As of now, there is no standard product marketed by any of the switchgear company. MCB will not work since the current will not go very high and RCCB will also not function since there is no leakage of current. One can think of homemade arrangement providing a three-pole 63A power contactor after incoming MCBs with the coil connected to phase and another to the neutral busbar at the distribution box. When neutral is disconnected, the coil will not get the supply and trip the contactor. A hand-drawn circuit is given below. A 63A TPN incoming is shown but one shall have a solid neutral connection.
About the Author:
Mr Mahesh Kumar Jain is an Alumnus of the University of Roorkee (IIT Roorkee) with a degree in Electrical Engineering who has spent 36 years serving the Indian Railways. He retired from Indian Railways as a Director of IREEN (Indian Railways Institute of Electrical Engineering) and has also served as Principal Chief Electrical Engineer at many Railways. He has performed the responsibility of working as Electrical Inspector to Govt. of India. Mr Mahesh Kumar Jain is having a passion for electrical safety, fire, reliability, electrical energy consumption/conservation/management, electrical appliances. He currently serves as a consultant at Nippon Koi Consortium in the field of power distribution and electric locomotive. More from this author.